Nov 16, 2026 · @David https://x.com/myrtlebeachnews
Recommended: “Bricks Don’t Have Free Speech”: Advocates Fight Builder’s Bid to Overturn Township Data Center Builder’s Free-Speech Claim Ban
Deck: A legal brief filed in federal court argues a New Jersey construction company can’t use the First Amendment to override a town’s zoning vote, a test case for communities weighing AI data centers.
This case highlights the implications of the Data Center Builder’s Free-Speech Claim in the ongoing debate over zoning laws.
Alternates
CAMDEN, N.J. — A tech accountability group has asked a federal judge to reject a construction company’s argument that a New Jersey township’s ban on data centers violates the First Amendment.

Tech Justice Law filed an amicus brief in the U.S. District Court for the District of New Jersey in the lawsuit brought by Hexa Builders against Monroe Township. The brief urges the court to throw out Hexa’s free-speech theory and to respect the township’s authority to make land-use decisions for its residents.
“The people of Monroe Township have used their First Amendment-protected freedom of speech to speak up against data centers,” said Meetali Jain, founding executive director of Tech Justice Law. “Hexa Builders’ bricks do not have that same right.”
The lawsuit challenges Monroe Township Council Ordinance O:25-2026, which bans data centers in every zoning district in the township.
According to Tech Justice Law, Hexa Builders had already received approval to build warehouses on the property. The company then sought to convert one of those buildings into a data center, even though it had no tenant lined up.
Hexa makes two main claims, according to the group’s summary of the suit:
Tech Justice Law’s brief rejects the idea that a building can carry free-speech protection. The group argues that building and operating a data center is not expressive activity, that data centers are not mediums of communication, and that AI output is not automatically speech.
Accepting Hexa’s theory, the group contends, would put ordinary zoning decisions about power plants, warehouses and other infrastructure under First Amendment scrutiny.
The brief also argues that local governments are best positioned to protect residents, even when new technology is involved. Weighing a large facility’s demands on water, energy and electricity, along with noise and cost to residents, is a core local responsibility, the group says. Because data centers are general-purpose infrastructure, it argues, the laws governing them should be treated as infrastructure rules rather than restrictions on a company’s speech.
“As Americans make it clear that they are not interested in tech companies building data centers in their community for dangerous Artificial Intelligence products, these companies are making increasingly ridiculous appeals to the law to let construction go forward,” Jain said. “It should be up to the people of Monroe Township, not outside actors with financial interests, to protect their residents, and the court must affirm their right to do so.”
The brief was co-authored by Olivier Sylvain, a professor at Fordham University School of Law, and Laura Bingham, practice professor of law and executive director of the Institute for Law, Innovation, and Technology (iLIT) at Temple University Beasley School of Law.

“This is little more than a cute attempt at an end run around lawful democratic lawmaking processes. There is nothing about the ordinance that impedes free speech,” Sylvain said. He called the township’s decision “a prudent exercise of democratic initiative” against facilities he described as “disproportionately extractive and costly for local residents.”
Bingham said local communities are “where the AI industry is meeting the democratic process in this country.”
“Hexa Builders seeks a Bill of Rights to serve its own interests,” she said. “No court, legislature, or community should bow to such a baseless demand. We have real problems to solve and communities like Monroe Township are hard at work doing just that.”

An amicus brief is filed by an outside party that is not part of the lawsuit. The judge may consider its arguments but is not bound by them. The case remains pending in federal court in Camden.
Myrtle Beach News has reached out to Hexa Builders for comment. [Update or remove before publishing.]
If a court accepted the idea that a data center is protected speech, every local zoning board in the country, including Horry and Georgetown county councils, would face a harder path to saying no.
Optional sidebar for local readers:
Open question: Are any data center projects pending or rumored in Horry or Georgetown counties? Worth a check of recent planning commission agendas before publishing this sidebar.